US judge rejects Gemini and CFTC bid to vacate $5M settlement
A federal judge declined a joint bid by Gemini and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to vacate a January 2025 consent judgment: the $5 million penalty and permanent injunction remain. Judge Alvin Hellerstein held that the parties did not meet the legal standards required to reopen the settlement, despite the CFTC’s changed enforcement priorities for digital assets. The original case alleged Gemini misled the regulator during its 2017 review of a proposed Bitcoin futures product.
When Regulators Change Their Minds
The CFTC revisited its earlier enforcement stance and, together with Gemini, sought to undo the judgment. The court ruled that a shift in policy does not erase a final order: the record did not justify vacatur. The ruling signals that courts retain control over their judgments and that policy reversals at agencies are insufficient grounds to unwind settled cases. Implication for the sector: firms should not expect historical crypto enforcement outcomes to be retroactively nullified due to evolving regulatory priorities.
What Changes For Gemini?
Immediate impact: no new penalties and the existing settlement stays in force. Ongoing constraints: the permanent injunction continues to apply. Broader takeaway: expectations of retroactive relief tied to a friendlier federal posture are unlikely to be met. This sets a precedent that previously approved settlements will persist regardless of subsequent policy shifts.
Authors credited by the source: NewsBTC Editorial Team
Published by Holder based on an external source.



